In the world of team management, we often obsess over hiring A-players, developing star performers, and building dream teams. But what if the secret to high performance isn’t about the people you choose—it’s about the environment you create for them?
The Shocking 40% Performance Drop: Setting the Record Straight
You may have seen viral posts referencing a study by “Professor Phelps” at “an Australian University.” While the story is compelling, the details matter—and at DECISION 168, we believe in getting the facts right.
The actual research was conducted by Will Felps, who was a doctoral student at the University of Washington Business School at the time, along with professors Terence R. Mitchell and Eliza Byington University of Washington Evergreen Leadership. The study was published in 2006 in Research in Organizational Behavior, and its findings remain profoundly relevant today.
Here’s what actually happened:
Felps and his colleagues examined 40 groups of four to five people, The Bad Apple Effect, giving them management problems to solve. Some groups unknowingly included trained actors who portrayed three distinct negative personas:
The Jerk – an aggressive, defiant individual who challenged others with hostility
The Slacker – someone who deliberately withheld effort while others worked
The Downer – a depressive personality type who radiated negativity and defeat The all-powerful bad apple – Mike Crittenden
The results were stunning.
Groups with these “bad apples” performed 30 to 40 percent worse than other groups The Bad Apple: Group Poison—even when the remaining team members were highly capable and motivated.
Think about that magnitude. Not 5%. Not 10%. Up to 40% performance destruction—from a single person exhibiting destructive behaviors.
(Note: Will Felps is now a professor at UNSW in Australia, which may explain some of the confusion in viral retellings of this research. But the original study took place at the University of Washington in Seattle.)
What We Get Wrong About “Bad Apples”
Here’s where most leaders misinterpret Felps’ research: they see it as evidence that they need to identify and remove problematic team members.
But that’s looking at the symptom, not the cause.
The real question isn’t “Who is the bad apple?”—it’s “Why is my tree producing bad apples?”
When someone on your team becomes disengaged, cynical, or discouraged, it’s rarely because they woke up one morning and decided to derail collaboration. More often, it’s a signal that something in your organizational environment is failing them.
Maybe they’re:
- Burned out from unrealistic expectations
- Feeling undervalued or unheard
- Struggling with personal challenges while lacking support
- Unclear about their role or purpose
- Working in conditions that make success nearly impossible
Labeling these individuals and removing them doesn’t solve the underlying problem. It just ensures the next person who struggles will face the same fate.
The Environment Principle: Healthy Trees Don’t Produce Rotten Fruit
You won’t have struggling team members if the whole environment is adequate.
This is the lesson organizations—and society—desperately need to learn. When teams consistently underperform or individuals consistently struggle, the first place to look isn’t at the people. It’s at the conditions you’ve created.
Great organizations understand this intuitively:
- They invest in employee well-being, not just productivity
- They create psychological safety where people can struggle without shame
- They build systems that catch problems early, before someone spirals
- They recognize that difficult moments in people’s lives require support, not labels
This isn’t just compassionate leadership—it’s practical leadership. Because the cost of losing a team member (recruitment, training, lost institutional knowledge, team disruption) almost always exceeds the cost of investing in their growth and happiness.
10 Daily Habits of Highly Productive Entrepreneurs That Can Transform You
The DECISION 168 Approach: Building Environments Where People Thrive
This is where productivity platforms like DECISION 168 reveal their true value—not as tools for identifying “problem employees,” but as systems for creating healthy organizational environments.
At DECISION 168, we’re committed to accuracy, evidence-based practices, and solutions that actually work. That’s why we take the time to understand the real research—not just the viral stories—and apply those insights to help you build better teams.
Creating Visibility for Support, Not Surveillance
DECISION 168’s team collaboration features help leaders understand how teams work together and where individuals might be struggling. Through structured workflows and transparent communication channels, leaders can identify when someone needs support before their struggles impact the entire team.
The platform’s productivity components enable effective team management by:
- Recognizing early warning signs: See when someone’s engagement drops, not to punish them, but to understand what they need
- Facilitating meaningful support: Identify collaboration breakdowns as opportunities for intervention and improvement
- Building accountability with compassion: Ensure every team member has clarity about their role and the resources to succeed
- Tracking patterns to improve systems: Build evidence-based understanding of what environmental factors help or hurt team performance
Proactive Culture Building Through Productivity Tools
With DECISION 168’s collaboration and productivity tools, leaders can create what Felps’ research actually demands: environments where struggling team members get support before they impact overall performance.
The platform enables this through:
Regular Check-Ins That Show You Care: Structured touchpoints that go beyond “How’s it going?” to genuinely understand what team members need to succeed.
Transparent Communication That Builds Trust: When communication flows through visible channels, people feel heard and problems surface early, before they escalate.
Clear Role Definition That Prevents Frustration: When people understand their purpose and have the tools to contribute, disengagement rarely develops.
Data-Driven Environment Assessment: Instead of subjective judgments about individuals, leaders gain objective insights into whether their organizational systems support success.
How to Motivate a Remote & In-Office Hybrid Team Without Micromanaging
Investment Over Elimination: The Real Solution
Felps’ research shouldn’t lead to the conclusion that we need to remove struggling team members. It should lead us to ask: What conditions allowed someone to reach this state in the first place?
The solution isn’t elimination—it’s investment:
Invest in education and development. When someone lacks skills, train them. When they lack confidence, mentor them. When they lack clarity, guide them.
Invest in well-being and happiness. Create work environments where people have reasonable workloads, feel valued, and have access to support when life gets hard.
Invest in psychological safety. Build cultures where struggling is seen as human, not as a termination-worthy offense.
Invest in systems that support success. Use tools like DECISION 168 to create transparent, collaborative environments where problems surface early and help is readily available.
DECISION 168’s productivity platform supports this investment approach by providing:
- Clear documentation that helps leaders understand patterns and identify systemic issues, not just individual struggles
- Communication tools that foster connection and prevent isolation
- Collaboration metrics that reveal when teams need additional resources or support
Everyone Deserves a Difficult Moment
Here’s an uncomfortable truth: Every single person will go through difficult moments in their life.
Loss. Illness. Family crisis. Mental health struggles. Burnout. Conflict.
The measure of an organization isn’t whether these moments happen—it’s how the organization responds when they do.
Do you label people who are struggling and push them out? Or do you recognize their humanity, offer support, and help them through it?
The first approach might give you short-term performance gains. The second approach builds loyalty, resilience, and a culture where people bring their best selves because they know they’re valued as whole human beings, not just productivity units.
Implementing the Environmental Mindset
Practical steps for leaders who want to apply Felps’ research correctly:
- Establish Environmental Health Checks Use DECISION 168’s collaboration features to regularly assess whether your systems support success. Don’t just ask about task completion—ask whether people have what they need to thrive.
- Make Support Visible and Accessible Create transparent channels where asking for help is normalized, not stigmatized. DECISION 168’s productivity platform can facilitate this by making collaboration and support part of the everyday workflow.
- Act Fast to Provide Resources When you spot someone struggling, don’t wait and hope it resolves itself. Intervene immediately with genuine support—whether that’s reducing workload, providing training, offering flexibility, or simply listening.
- Protect Your Team Members Your people are your most valuable asset. If organizational conditions are causing them to struggle, fix the conditions. Make the hard decisions about systems, not about people.
- Measure Environmental Health, Not Just Individual Performance DECISION 168 allows leaders to track not just deliverables but collaboration quality, communication patterns, and team engagement—the indicators of whether your environment supports success.
The Bottom Line for Modern Leaders
Will Felps and his colleagues proved something profound: one struggling team member can significantly impact overall performance.
But the response to this finding shouldn’t be elimination—it should be environmental improvement.
When your team consistently has people who are disengaged, discouraged, or skeptical, that’s not a people problem. That’s an organizational problem.
The solution is clear:
Inspect your environment. Use platforms like DECISION 168 to gain visibility into whether your systems support success.
Invest in your people. When someone struggles, provide education, support, and resources—not labels and exits.
Build for humanity. Create conditions where difficult moments don’t destroy careers, because you’ve built an environment that catches people when they fall.
This isn’t just the right way to run a company—it’s the right way to build a society. Organizations that invest in the education, well-being, and happiness of their people don’t just perform better. They create ripples of positive impact that extend far beyond their walls.
At DECISION 168, we’re committed to helping you build these environments. We believe in getting the research right, understanding the real causes of team dysfunction, and providing tools that support human flourishing—not just productivity metrics.
Effective leadership requires more than inspecting what people produce—it demands creating conditions where people can thrive, even during their most difficult moments.
The question isn’t whether you have struggling team members. The question is: What kind of environment are you creating, and is it worthy of the people who show up to work in it every day?
Ready to transform your organizational environment and create conditions where every team member can thrive? Discover how DECISION 168’s productivity and team collaboration platform—built on accurate research and evidence-based practices—can help you build supportive systems, maintain team health, and invest in your people’s success. Create a free account at app.decision168.com to learn more.












